Summer Reading Contest Winner, Week 5: On ‘Hamilton Review: You Say You Want a Revolution’

Summer Reading Contest Winner, Week 5: On ‘Hamilton Review: You Say You Want a Revolution’

Ava Hyde, 16, from Dell Regional High School in Oradell, N.J. chose an article headlined “‘Hamilton’ Review: You Say You Want a Revolution and wrote:

Because I was once one of *those* kids back in 2016, you know, the kid who knew the entire Hamilton soundtrack by heart and dressed as Thomas Jefferson for Halloween (which is still horrifying to me after realizing the irony of that costume choice as a biracial girl), I was instantly drawn to click on A.O. Scott’s “‘Hamilton’ Review: You Say You Want a Revolution.” I wanted to see if, like myself, the critic’s view on the musical had changed given the current political climate.

Many people have drifted away from the optimism and patriotism described in this review. Twitter even called to “cancel” the musical because of the way it celebrates slave owners. My old favorite character, the jazzy and comical Thomas Jefferson, owned over 600 slaves. The iconic, soulful George Washington was an active slave owner for 56 years. Knowing this, and knowing how the slavery discussed as a side note in ‘Hamilton’ has lived on through economic and social inequalities, I feel that I’ve lost the optimism of that twelve-year-old girl blasting “My Shot” in my mom’s car.

When I read the critique that the show is “heartbreaking” as well as inspiring, I knew that I wasn’t alone in realizing that there have never been “good old days” to romanticize. I am also left to wonder if the cast of black and Hispanic actors as our founding fathers was truly intended to be an empowering statement about our whitewashed history, or if it’s a crutch used to avoid the topic of race that is so prominent today.

In alphabetical order by the writer’s first name.

Adora on “I’m the President of M.I.T. America Needs Foreign Students.”

Huda on “I Am Here to Prove You Wrong

Lang on “You Should Start Writing Letters

Ore James on “The Baby-Sitters Club Taught Me Everything I Needed to Know About Literary Fiction

Sam on “Hong Kong, Changed Overnight, Navigates its New Reality

Sinead on “Yeah, Let’s Not Talk About Race

Yuxuan on “Who Belongs in America?

Amy Zhang Liu on “Why We’re Capitalizing Black

Andrew on “What Is Freedom? Teaching Kids Philosophy in a Pandemic

Avi on “The Specter of Caste in Silicon Valley

Bettina Tang on “Talking to Kids About Racism, Early and Often